Comparing BarkBox vs Chewy: Which Subscription Service is Right for Your Pet?

Discover the best subscription service for your furry friend! Read our comparison of BarkBox and Chewy to find out which one offers the most value, variety, and convenience for your pet’s needs..

Are you a pet parent looking to spoil your furry friend with a monthly subscription service? You’re not alone – pet subscription boxes have become increasingly popular in recent years, offering a convenient and exciting way to treat your pet to new toys and treats. Two popular subscription services on the market today are BarkBox and Chewy, but how do they compare? Here, we’ll break down the features and benefits of each, helping you make the right choice for your beloved pet.

Understanding Pet Subscription Services

Pet subscription services are becoming increasingly popular among pet owners who want to provide their furry friends with the best possible products without the hassle of going to the pet store or searching online. These monthly deliveries of toys, treats, and other products are curated to cater to pets of all sizes, breeds, and ages, making it easy to find the perfect box for your furry friend.

One of the best things about pet subscription services is that they take the guesswork out of shopping for your pet. You no longer have to wonder if a certain toy or treat will be suitable for your pet. With these services, you can rest assured that your pet will receive high-quality products that are safe, healthy, and fun.

What are Pet Subscription Services?

If you’re new to the world of pet subscription services, you might be wondering what they are exactly. Simply put, these services are curated boxes of pet products that are delivered straight to your doorstep each month. They are designed to provide your pet with a variety of toys, treats, and other products that are tailored to their specific needs and preferences.

For example, if you have a small dog, you can choose a box that is specifically designed for small breeds. If you have a senior dog, you can choose a box that contains products that are suitable for older dogs. These boxes make it easy to find the perfect products for your pet without having to spend hours researching and shopping.

Benefits of Pet Subscription Services

There are numerous benefits to subscribing to a pet subscription service like BarkBox or Chewy. Firstly, you’ll have access to high-quality, innovative pet products that are often not available in stores. These products are carefully selected by experts who understand what pets need and what they enjoy.

Secondly, subscribing to a pet subscription service can save you time and energy. Rather than having to go to the pet store or search online for products, the products are automatically delivered to your doorstep each month. This means that you can spend more time playing with your pet and less time shopping for them.

Finally, subscribing to a pet subscription service can be a fun way to bond with your pet. You can try out new toys and treats together, and your pet will love the excitement of receiving a new box each month. It’s a great way to keep your pet entertained and engaged, and to show them how much you care.

In conclusion, pet subscription services are a fantastic way to provide your pet with high-quality, innovative products without the hassle of shopping. They are convenient, fun, and can help strengthen the bond between you and your furry friend.

BarkBox: A Closer Look

BarkBox is a monthly subscription service for dogs, offering a variety of toys, treats, and chews. They offer plans for dogs of all sizes and ages, making it easy to choose the best box for your furry friend. Whether you have a small, medium, or large dog, BarkBox has got you covered.

As a dog owner, you know how important it is to keep your furry friend entertained and happy. With BarkBox, you can rest assured that your dog will receive a variety of high-quality toys and treats each month.

How BarkBox Works

When choosing a BarkBox subscription, you’ll select a plan based on your dog’s size. Then, each month, a box will be delivered to your doorstep filled with 2 toys, 2 bags of natural treats, and 1 chew. Their toys are designed in-house and are often themed around holidays or current events, ensuring that your dog is always entertained.

What sets BarkBox apart from other pet subscription services is their commitment to quality. All of their products are made from high-quality materials and are sourced from trusted vendors. This means that you can feel good about giving your dog the best of the best.

BarkBox Pricing and Plans

BarkBox offers several pricing plans depending on the length of subscription you choose. Monthly subscribers can expect to pay $35 per month, while a six-month plan costs $25 per month, and a twelve-month plan costs $22 per month. If you’re looking to save money in the long run, it’s worth considering the six or twelve-month plan.

Another thing to keep in mind is that BarkBox often offers special deals and discounts, so it’s always worth checking their website for the latest offers.

BarkBox Pros and Cons

One of the major pros of BarkBox is the quality of their products. All of their products are sourced from trusted vendors and are made from high-quality materials. Additionally, their customer service team is often praised for their helpfulness and responsiveness. If you ever have any issues with your subscription, you can rest assured that BarkBox will take care of you.

Potential cons may include the price, as BarkBox is one of the more expensive pet subscription services on the market. However, many dog owners feel that the quality of the products justifies the price. It’s also worth noting that BarkBox often includes items in their boxes that are not available in stores, making the subscription feel even more special.

Overall, BarkBox is a great choice for dog owners who want to treat their furry friends to high-quality toys and treats each month. With a variety of plans to choose from, you’re sure to find the perfect subscription for your dog’s needs.

Chewy: A Closer Look

Chewy is a popular online retailer for pet products, offering everything from food to toys to grooming supplies. They pride themselves on being a one-stop-shop for all your pet needs, making it easy for pet owners to find and purchase everything they need in one place.

Founded in 2011, Chewy has quickly grown to become one of the largest online pet retailers in the United States. Their mission is to make pet ownership as convenient and affordable as possible, and they have succeeded in doing just that.

How Chewy Works

Chewy’s Autoship program is one of their most popular features. It allows you to select products that you need regularly, such as food or litter, and have them delivered automatically each month. This means you never have to worry about running out of essential pet supplies again.

Additionally, they offer a program called Chewy Go, which sends a box of toys and treats each month. You can customize the products in each box to fit your pet’s preferences, making it a fun surprise for both you and your furry friend.

Chewy Pricing and Plans

Chewy Go starts at $29.95 per month, but the price can vary depending on the products you choose. The Autoship program offers a 5-10% discount on products, making it a great option for pet owners who need to regularly stock up on essentials.

Chewy also offers free shipping on orders over $49, which is a great perk for those who want to save money on shipping costs.

Chewy Pros and Cons

Chewy’s vast product selection and competitive prices make them a go-to for pet owners. They offer a wide range of products from well-known brands such as Blue Buffalo, Purina, and Friskies, as well as lesser-known brands that are often hard to find in stores.

Additionally, their customer service team is well-known for their helpfulness and efficiency. They offer 24/7 support via phone, email, and live chat, making it easy to get help whenever you need it.

One potential downside of Chewy is that their products are not curated specifically for each pet, meaning that some products may not be suitable for all pets. However, they do offer a satisfaction guarantee, so if you are not happy with a product you can return it for a full refund.

Overall, Chewy is a great option for pet owners who want to save time and money on pet supplies. With their Autoship program and Chewy Go boxes, you can ensure that your pet always has everything they need, without ever having to leave your house.

Comparing BarkBox and Chewy

Choosing the right subscription box for your furry friend can be a daunting task. Two of the most popular options on the market today are BarkBox and Chewy. Both of these companies offer a wide variety of products and services, making it difficult to decide which one is the best fit for you and your pet. In this article, we will take a closer look at the customization options, product quality and variety, and customer service and support offered by both BarkBox and Chewy.

Customization Options

When it comes to customization options, BarkBox and Chewy both offer unique features that cater to different needs. BarkBox offers customization based on your dog’s size, making it easy to choose the right box for your pup. They also offer the option to add extra toys or treats to your box for an additional fee. Chewy, on the other hand, offers customization through their Autoship program and Chewy Go program. These programs allow you to tailor your monthly box or recurring shipments to your pet’s specific needs. For example, if your pet has a food allergy, you can choose to exclude certain ingredients from their monthly box.

One thing to note is that BarkBox only offers one box size, so if you have a larger dog, you may need to purchase additional toys or treats separately. Chewy’s customization options are more flexible in this regard, as you can choose the size and type of products you want in your box.

Product Quality and Variety

Both BarkBox and Chewy offer high-quality products from trusted vendors. BarkBox’s products are curated specifically for each box, ensuring that your pet receives a unique and exciting selection of toys and treats each month. Chewy’s products can be customized through their Autoship and Chewy Go programs, allowing you to choose the brands and types of products you prefer.

One advantage of BarkBox is that their products are often exclusive to their subscription service, meaning that you won’t find them in stores. This can add an element of excitement and surprise to each box. Chewy, on the other hand, offers a wider variety of products, including food, grooming supplies, and medication.

Customer Service and Support

When it comes to customer service and support, both BarkBox and Chewy have excellent reputations. BarkBox offers a satisfaction guarantee, promising to replace any products that your pet doesn’t like. They also have a dedicated customer service team that is available to answer any questions or concerns you may have.

Chewy also has a 24/7 customer service hotline for any questions or concerns. They offer free shipping on orders over $49 and have a generous return policy. If you’re not satisfied with a product, you can return it for a full refund or exchange.

In conclusion, both BarkBox and Chewy offer unique features and benefits that cater to different pet owners. If you’re looking for a subscription box that offers customization based on your dog’s size, BarkBox may be the best fit for you. If you prefer a wider variety of products and more flexible customization options, Chewy may be the way to go. Regardless of which option you choose, you can rest assured that your pet will receive high-quality products and excellent customer service.

Making the Right Choice for Your Pet

As a pet owner, you want to give your furry friend the best possible care. This includes providing them with high-quality food, toys, and treats. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. Two popular options are BarkBox and Chewy.

Assessing Your Pet’s Needs

When deciding between BarkBox and Chewy, it’s important to consider your pet’s specific needs. For example, if you have a small dog, you may want to choose a service that offers toys and treats specifically designed for their size. Similarly, if you have an older pet, you may want to choose a service that offers products that cater to their age-related needs.

Another factor to consider is your pet’s preferences. Some dogs may love themed toys and natural treats, which are offered by BarkBox. On the other hand, if your pet has specific dietary requirements or preferences, Chewy may be a better choice as they offer a wide variety of customizable options.

Budget Considerations

When it comes to budget, BarkBox is generally more expensive than Chewy Go. However, BarkBox offers a discount for longer commitments, which can make it a more affordable option in the long run. On the other hand, Chewy offers a discount for Autoship orders, making it a more affordable option for regularly needed items like food and litter.

It’s important to consider your budget and your pet’s needs when choosing between the two services.

Trying Out Both Services

If you’re still unsure which service is right for your pet, consider trying out both. Both BarkBox and Chewy offer cancellation options, meaning you can cancel if you’re not satisfied with the products or service. This will give you a chance to see which service your pet prefers and which offers the best value for your money.

Overall, choosing between BarkBox and Chewy depends on your pet’s specific needs and your budget. By considering these factors and trying out both services, you can make an informed decision and give your pet the best possible care.

Other Pet Subscription Services to Consider

Are you looking for even more options when it comes to pet subscription services? Here are a few other services to consider:


If you have a new puppy, PupBox might be the perfect subscription service for you. In addition to toys and treats, PupBox also delivers training guides to help you raise a well-behaved and happy pup. Each box is tailored to your puppy’s age and size, so you can be sure you’re getting products that are just right for your furry friend.

Pet Treater

Pet Treater offers monthly boxes for both dogs and cats, making it a great option for households with multiple pets. Each box includes toys, treats, and accessories, and you can choose between a regular box or a Deluxe box for an even more exciting haul. Pet Treater also donates a portion of their proceeds to animal shelters and rescues, so you can feel good about supporting a company that gives back.


Cat owners, rejoice! KitNipBox delivers monthly boxes filled with toys, treats, and other goodies to keep your feline friend entertained. Each box includes high-quality, all-natural products that are sure to delight your cat. Plus, KitNipBox partners with animal welfare organizations to help support cats in need.

No matter which pet subscription service you choose, you can enjoy the convenience of having high-quality pet products delivered right to your door. Plus, with so many options available, you’re sure to find a service that meets your needs and budget.

Conclusion: BarkBox vs Chewy

Choosing between BarkBox and Chewy ultimately depends on your pet’s needs, preferences, and your budget. It’s important to consider the pros and cons of each service, and possibly try out both before committing to a subscription. Ultimately, both services offer exciting and high-quality products for pets, making it easy to spoil your furry friend month after month.

Similar Posts